Online ordering powered by Seamless
2350 Broadway (212) 496-4004
Minimum order of $0.00 is required for delivery
Delivery estimate is 25-40 min (more info)
Unfortunately, Cafe 86 (Formerly Cafe on Broadway) is not open at the delivery/pickup time that you selected. Please make sure that you've entered an address and try changing the time in the Order Information section to the right.
Seamless allows you to enjoy convenient online ordering from the best local restaurants. If you're ordering for the first time, start your order by entering your address to the right. Return users log in here.
Minimum order of $0.00 is required for delivery
Delivery estimate is 20 - 35 min (more info)
Print this menu
Available all day.
All omelettes made with 2 eggs. Served with home fries and toast.
Available all day. Choice of wrap.
The perfect accompaniment to your sandwich, soup or salad.
All our salad bar ingredients and vegetables are fresh from the fields and markets. No preservatives or additives ever used...all natural!
Crisp, refreshing and all-natural. Served with your choice of any of our homemade dressings and brick oven dinner roll.
A Southwestern blend of melted Cheddar & Jack cheese, caramelized onions, roasted peppers & poblano chilies on a grilled tortilla.
Made with freshly ground 8oz. Prime Black Angus Beef, 100% pure turkey meat, or homemade veggie garden burger. Served grilled as you like it!
After a hectic day, all you want is a mouth watering delicious hot meal. Order from Café on Broadway’s extensive selection of eclectic offerings and your hunger is sure to be satisfied! Try their catering options for private parties, luncheons, picnics, or office get-togethers. Even their signature salads are fresh and crisp to the last bite!
Turkey Bacon Guacamole—Real turkey breast, crispy smoked bacon, pepper jack cheese, guacamole and ranch dressing in a sourdough panini served hot
Oven Roasted Fresh Turkey—Roasted peppers, sliced avocado, caramelized onions, plum tomatoes and watercress; served with peppercorn mayo on a whole grain French roll
Philly Cheese Steak—Prime roast beef, grilled mushrooms, peppers, onions and melted cheese on a semolina hero
Grilled Chicken Quesadillas—Blend of melted cheddar and jack cheese, caramelized onions, roasted peppers and poblano chilies on a grilled tortilla; served with sour cream, pico de gallo salsa and homemade guacamole
Flame Kissed Deluxe Burgers—Six ounce prime angus beef, one hundred percent pure turkey meat or homemade garden burgers; served with steak fries, lettuce, tomatoes, cheese and a kosher dill pickle
Grilled Salmon Filet
Extremely fast delivery, fries weren't soggy, exactly as ordered, food is up to par. Will order from these guys again.
Posted 11 months ago by Erin D.
Good value and quality. Prompt too.
Posted a year ago by allison d.
Quick delivery and affordable prices. Love the sweet potato fries
Posted a year ago by Ian S.
Cafe 86 has an amazing selection and the food is delicious! Also, they were quick to deliver and had convenient hours.
Posted a year ago by Colleen B.
Order salad from them at least 3 times a week. Always happy with my order....
Posted a year ago by rebecca r.
Not the best food or the hottest when it arrives but it's cheap and gets here quick.
Posted a year ago by Jamie M.
Great sandwiches, fast delivery and a pretty good price
Posted a year ago by William O.
Great food especially breakfast- Florentine omelet on croissant yum! Their smoothies are delicious!
Posted a year ago by Jessica H.
They have a great mixed salad, they always get it right. And they are always quick. Great for late night burger and fries platter.
Posted a year ago by Kimberly B.
I've tried a bunch of different sandwiches and they're all fresh and delicious. Fast delivery.
Posted a year ago by Lia C.
I've been ordering from Cafe 86 regularly for nine months. Delivery is always fast, very good and hot/cold as it should be. I'm never disappointed.
Posted a year ago by Anne C.
Great value and quality
Posted a year ago by Lynn F.
Good for a quick easy bite to eat when I'm in a rush - nothing fancy, but it was tasty
Posted a year ago by Bronte H.
Delicious well-cooked burger, lovely potato-y steak fries. Very generous portions of both!
Posted a year ago by Vallari A.
Huge delicious salad!
Posted a year ago by Emily S.
Cafe 86 never fails to satisfy! BEST salad bar on the UWS. High quality toppings and generous portions. Also love that they give you the option to have your salad chopped. Their turkey chili is amazing (I only wish they carried it daily). Fast delivery! Several times I received the food in my hands not even 10 minutes after getting the confirmation email. Friendly staff and plenty of space to eat inside if you happen to drop in.
Posted a year ago by Taylor V.
Ordered the Chinese chicken salad, it was truly awful. Not sure how you can mess up this basic salad, but they do. Only reason I gave it a second star is because the dressing was ok. Other items from this place are good, but avoid this salad.
Posted a year ago by Erica B.
Always order from here and always good delivery. I had to write a review today because it's snowing/sleeting out and I decided to get delivery (yes, i felt somewhat guilty).
The NICEST delivery guy showed up and apologized for taking just 40 minutes to delivery in this awful weather. So rare in NYC, so thanks to that delivery dude!!
Posted a year ago by Mike C.
Amazingly fast delivery, food is good, have ordered from here many times, can't get better than that.
Posted a year ago by j s l.
The chicken fingers are delicious. Not what I expected as I kind of expected fast food like chicken fingers but these were way better. Adult chicken fingers if you will. Fast delivery, good food.
Posted a year ago by Josephine K.
The food is always nice, hot and tasty. Definitely one of the best places to order from. Very diverse menu as well. Food arrives quickly.
Posted a year ago by Pj R.
Had a hankering for a burger after work one morning around 7:30am. Ordered the Santa Fe burger (comes with curly fries). Within 20 mins, I had a hot tin of burger and fries in my lap. Burger was good, perhaps a little dry (ordered medium, in case you're wondering), but quite flavorful with the toppings. Fries were good and surprisingly still crisp. Pickle was so-so. All in all, I'd give this place a thumbs up for satisfying a random morning burger craving and doing it decently and speedily. Would I order from this place again? Lunch/dinner would be a maybe, but for a morning burger craving, most definitely.
Posted a year ago by Leslie W.
Always dependable. Consistently good quality food.
Posted a year ago by Stephanie P.
Fast delivery a food was warm, but possibly the worst burger I've ever had - dry, one piece of bacon, no ranch which I asked for, and the bun was burnt. Mashed potatoes were decent.
Posted a year ago by Jenna M.
Fast delievery, reasonable prices, and food is always hot. Great place to order in breakfast on your day off
Posted a year ago by Denise D.
Posted a year ago by Jason M.
Pretty standard diner type food, but very delicious in terms of quality. Their steak fries are great and their Middle Eastern platter will leave you full!
Posted 2 years ago by Carla E.
I love the create your own pasta option! It's affordable and has a good variety of add ins to choose from. I'd much rather spend $8 for shrimp pasta than $20 at a lot of the Italian places around here. Delivery is timely and friendly! This is definitely my go-to spot!
Posted 2 years ago by Patrika C.
Speedy delivery, good portions, fresh food.
Posted 2 years ago by Jennifer B.
Friendly service, great food. I order breakfast from this cafe at least twice a week.
Posted 2 years ago by Andrea C.
Always fast, delicious, and hot.
Posted 2 years ago by Patricia F.
NEVER order from this place. If Seamless does not complete your transaction properly you are left TRYING to speak to a RUDE, BARELY speaking English person at Cafe on Broadway. If you want bland, tasteless food.. order at your own risk.
Posted 2 years ago by Chad N.
Speedy food made with fresh ingredients. If you want a wide selection of food that is on par with or better than most diners and made with fresh ingredients, go with the Cafe on Broadway. Prompt and friendly service! Wraps, sandwiches and endless other lunch/breakfast options are not only made to order but are fast and delicious.
Posted 2 years ago by David C.
Cafe on Broadway is the old stand-by for me. Pretty straight forward fare and surprisingly sophisticated make-your-own salad bar. Food seems fresh, always tasty and whenever they've made a mistake (and there have been a few as I order from them an awful lot) they are not only quick to resolve the situation but go out of their way to do so. great baked goods too. I usually make a spinach salad but they have great burgers and excellent baked goods as well.
Posted 2 years ago by David F.
Got a classic cheeseburger from here with a side of steak fries. Cheeseburger was so good! The meat was done perfectly and the bun was flaky and buttery. I'm not a big red meat eater so eating this was a change but a great one! Also the delivery took barely 20 minutes. I will definitely be ordering from here again!!
Posted 2 years ago by Nicole B.
Cafe on Broadway never lets me down. Consistently great food, fast delivery and great customer service. Big fan of their burger and tropical tango smoothie.
Posted 2 years ago by Rachael L.
absolutely horrible. The menu options look good but the quality is bad. The bread is too hard and the turkey was just ba.
Posted 2 years ago by Natasha Y.
Love this smoothie!
Posted 2 years ago by tosha h.
Delicious food, very friendly and fast delivery. Pesto Penne is awesome and so is the Turkey Bacon Guac panini...Lobster bisque is very creamy, not huge chunks of lobster but fresh and tasty and cheap! Salads are huge...small comes in those plastic dome salad containers and small seems large!
Posted 2 years ago by Jim L.
Love this place, their Superbowel specials were a delight. Wish they kept them available year round. Good prices too.
Posted 2 years ago by Caroline A.
Am changing my review after a sandwich and chips took OVER AN HOUR a week ago. When I called, they had no idea where the delivery guy was. Needless to say, I won't be ordering from them again.
Posted 2 years ago by Jeff G.
Twice they didn't get my order right. Decent french fries though.
Posted 2 years ago by Alexis G.
Great food, fast delivery, friendly service. The burgers and sandwiches are delicious.
Posted 3 years ago by David H.
Bland does not begin to describe this place... food quantity/quality is low. Not worth your time
Posted 3 years ago by JAMES D.
I thought these guys had decent prices, until I received my order and experienced how bad and bland the quality of the food was. I won't be ordering from this place again. Ripoff.
Posted 3 years ago by Jesus G.
Hands down the worst Italian hero I've ever had
Posted 3 years ago by Brian L.
Love this place for sandwiches & fries -- crazy-fast delivery and the turkey club is great!
Posted 3 years ago by Jennifer M.
Good, cheap, fast delivery.
Posted 4 years ago by Sam K.
Italian Hero was terrible. Meat and lettuce were not very fresh and the "Semolina Hero" was more like a semolina hot dog bun.
Posted 4 years ago by hannah p.
Cheap, quick, and tasty.
Posted 4 years ago by Zachary H.
UPDATED: The delivery people they have right now are REALLY nice. Also, it's not on the menu, but if you ask for salad greens instead of potatoes in the comments when ordering an omelet, they will do it!
Overview: A good go-to for an everyday lunch or working dinner.
Good: prices, desserts, sandwiches, drink selection
So-so: salads don't seem very fresh
UPDATED: prepared salads aren't the freshest, but the "create your own" salads are very, very good.
Bad: They keep sending me Diet Pepsi instead of Diet Coke! Maybe nitpicky, but they aren't the same!
UPDATED: This has gotten much better. Almost never happens anymore! :)
Posted 4 years ago by Amy C.
great soup and quiche!
Posted 4 years ago by Adam A.
Fantastic for what it is - fast yummy food.
Always understand my "off-menu" instructions
Salads are really good.
Posted 4 years ago by Susan W.
my favorite go-to spot on seamless web! fast delivery, cheap prices, great food!
Posted 4 years ago by Kirsten J.
I order from this place with an embarrassing frequency. Their sandwiches are great (my favorite it the Chicken Tijuana), and their soups are always flavorful. Great for deli food.
Posted 4 years ago by Amy K.
They always deliver fast and efficiently - and the food is scrumptious. Best burger in the area as far as I'm concerned. Yum Yum!
Posted 4 years ago by Natasha C.
Substituted food without asking me and then wouldn't refund money - AVOID!!
Posted 4 years ago by Danielle J.
great food-great prices
Posted 4 years ago by Debra G.
Great sandwiches, mediocre smoothies (inconsistent), fast delivery.
Posted 5 years ago by Christina H.
The absolute worst food ever. Inedible, truly. Had to throw it away.
Posted 5 years ago by Kenneth g.
They delivered the wrong thing in my order. When I called them, they said not to open the container with the entree that they had mistakenly delivered, and they would send me a new one. I appreciate them fixing my order, but if they're re-sending food from one customer's home to another, I won't be ordering from here again.
Posted 5 years ago by Lisa Selwitz S.
solid diner food
Posted 5 years ago by Danielle M.
Great food, fast service! Cafe on Broadway is one of my favorites!
Posted 6 years ago by Sarah S.
yum-o. super tasty and cheap
Posted 6 years ago by Read F.
Posted 6 years ago by Caroline A.
Only select user reviews are published on Seamless. All user-submitted ratings contribute to Cafe 86 (Formerly Cafe on Broadway)'s overall Seamless rating, but we manually screen all reviews and only publish those that are relevant and helpful. Tips for getting your review published »
Above content provided by restaurant.
Order online from
Cafe 86 (Formerly Cafe on Broadway) by entering your address
below. Online ordering powered by Seamless.com.
Return users log
Click a menu item to add it to your order.
Back to top
Seamless North America, LLC. All Rights Reserved.
0808 234 7862
Seamless North America, LLC. All Rights Reserved.